86 pages • 2 hours read
Alan GratzA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Dee has been hiding behind the seawall he ran to in Chapter 34. He and the soldiers who are also taking cover there watch a new boat of Americans arrive at the beach. Many of the soldiers who try to get out of the boat are shot, but one runs out of the boat, behind a tank, and then behind a metal anti-tank structure. The soldier narrowly avoids an explosion, makes it to one safe zone, and then is shot while he tries to get to the seawall. Dee is devastated and runs out to retrieve the soldier’s body in recognition of the other’s courage.
Dee sees Henry struggling while he helps a wounded soldier, and he rushes out from the wall to help him. Henry introduces himself and treats a couple of Dee’s cuts. To his surprise and delight, Dee realizes that the soldier Henry was helping is Sid. Dee had thought his friend was dead after the explosion in Chapter 27.
After Dee and Sid happily reunite, a commanding officer comes along the seawall and tells all the soldiers to go through a hole in the wall nearby to try and get off the beach, which he feels is a disadvantageous position. Dee realizes he doesn’t have a weapon and takes the rifle of the soldier whose body he retrieved.
The Americans rush through the seawall and up onto a bluff in front of a German bunker that they are going to try to capture. Smoke from burning seagrass keeps the Germans from hitting them, and Dee kills his first German soldier, a boy about his own age. He thinks of his heritage as a native German citizen and determines to become an official citizen of the US if he makes it out of the war alive.
The group of Ally soldiers Dee is with capture the German bunker, killing all the soldiers inside. After Dee gets his bearings, he realizes that the Allies are going to have to leave the beach and continue pushing inland.
Dee and Sid, along with the other American soldiers, leave Omaha Beach and check for civilians in an apparently deserted village. However, they are soon ambushed by German soldiers, who have a tank.
The Allies strategize about how to try and take out the tank. They cobble together small explosives to make a larger bomb, and after remembering the debt he feels to the US for offering his family a safe haven, Dee volunteers to carry the bomb to the tank, even though it’s likely that he’ll be killed. He sprints to the tank, throws the explosive, and is knocked backwards by the blast and is also hit by a bullet.
Dee survives the attack on the tank, which is immobilized after being hit. Dee crawls underneath the tank for shelter and realizes he can overhear and understand the Nazis inside, speaking in German. The soldiers give orders to set the village church on fire, which confuses Dee until he realizes that the Nazis have rounded up the villagers and trapped them inside the church. He realizes he must help the villagers escape, just as a grenade rolls to his hiding place under the tank.
The grenade near Dee turns out to be a smoke grenade, not an explosive, and Sid pulls him out from underneath the tank to safety. Dee tells Sid what he overheard, forcing him to explain to his friend that he was born in Germany. He rushes off to the burning church before he can fully see Sid’s reaction, and then finds that his friend has followed him with a rifle pointed in his direction.
Despite the menacing nature of Sid’s gesture, Dee realizes that his friend is going to use his rifle to shoot some of the church siding off to help the citizens inside escape. The two work together to get the French residents out of the church, joined by the other Ally soldiers after the Germans defending the village surrender. However, Sid ignores Dee, angry at his deception and his heritage.
The group decides to push on toward Bayeux, and Sid volunteers to stay behind with the Nazi soldiers who have been captured. Dee realizes that Sid means to execute the Germans while the rest of the soldiers are gone. He tries to persuade Sid not to murder them, but Sid only threatens to kill Dee, too, and Dee leaves dejectedly. He is brought down by a bullet on his way out of the village, implying that Sid might have shot his erstwhile friend.
Dee’s story reaches two emotional cruxes in this section of the book. First, he decides that he wants to become an American citizen officially, rather than the “enemy alien” (13) that he is classified as before the war. Both the narrative and the Author’s Note point out that many foreign-born immigrants served in Ally armies: “More than 300,000 immigrants served in the US armed forces during the war, a third of them non-citizens” (313). Patriotism, in Gratz’s story, depends not on where someone was born or what their background is, but instead on the reason each person chooses to serve. Rather than subscribe to Nazi ideology, Dee’s parents leave Germany. Samira and her mother help defend France against Germany, even though they face discrimination as Algerians. Sid later summarizes the idea of patriotism being about character rather than birth: “I kept thinking how you were a better man than all of us, even if you were a Kraut. Sorry—a German. And that there had to be some reason you were on our side, and not theirs” (304). Dee’s actions during the battle prove to himself and to Sid that he is a “true” American, not a Nazi.
The second emotional climax is Dee’s revelation to Sid about his heritage. Sid’s own identity as a Jew, the main group targeted by Hitler’s Nazis, make the emotional stakes of this deception even higher. Dee has been dreading what his friend would do if he found out that he is German by birth. Gratz crafts Sid’s reaction to be ambiguous to the reader. First, Sid follows Dee menacingly with a rifle, and both Dee and the reader think that he might shoot his friend. However, Gratz undermines this expectation by instead having Sid use the rifle to help get the French villagers out of the church. Afterward, it’s clear that Sid is in fact angry at Dee, and the gunshots Dee hears as he’s leaving the village are described in such a way (there are five gunshots and five Nazi captives) that implies that Sid has not heeded Dee’s advice to let the prisoners live. The tension created by these implications is not resolved until the end of the book, when Sid reveals that not only did he listen to his friend, Dee’s commitment to America influenced him. The friends end the story reconciled, the emotional rift between them repaired.
By Alan Gratz