62 pages • 2 hours read
Cao XueqinA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
After the long months of preparing for Yuan-chun’s visit, the family cleans up and takes a rest. The more idle of anyone is Bao-yu, who spends his days wandering, watching plays at Cousin Zhen’s, and doing other mindless things. One day, Aroma leaves the go visit her family for a meal, and Bao-yu becomes bored after the plays at Cousin Zhen’s become too loud and boisterous for his taste. He decides to go look at a portrait of a beautiful woman, and instead finds Tealeaf having sex with a young servant. He and Tealeaf sneak off to find Aroma at her house and are welcomed in for tea despite being chastised for leaving the house without asking permission.
It is obvious at Aroma’s house that Bao-yu is much more well-off. The family worries about him being warm enough and cater to him. Aroma is embarrassed at the dismal display of foods, knowing Bao-yu couldn’t be expected to eat such meager things. Finally, Bao-yu and Tealeaf take a cab home. At home, Aroma manipulates Bao-yu to avoid one of his fits, and then gets an idea to manipulate him further to get him to behave better. She and Bao-yu talk about Aroma leaving his service, and Bao-yu becomes deeply upset. Aroma explains the situation to him, “There’s no future for me here. Naturally I want to rejoin them [my family]” (387). Bao-yu replies, “You can’t if I won’t let you” (387), but Aroma argues and finally convinces him that she has agreed to leave in one year. Bao-yu leaves, sobbing, and Aroma’s plot is revealed: She is trying to humble Bao-yu so that she can persuade him to change his behavior. She tells him that she will stay only if he fulfills her three requests, all about his behavior. He agrees, and Aroma is pleased.
The next day, Bao-yu bothers Dai-yu because Aroma is too sick to entertain him. Dai-yu is trying to sleep, but Bao-yu won’t let her. Bao-yu is obsessed with the perfume on her sleeve, a “subtle fragrance which … caused one to feel rather limp” (394). He asks her persistent questions and finally tells her a made-up fable about her home province to stop her from dozing off. Dai-yu feels as if his story makes a mockery of her, calling her a “sweet potato” (398). Bao-chai interrupts them and takes Dai-yu’s side, and the chapter ends when all three hear a commotion coming from Bao-yu’s room.
The commotion in the other room is Nannie Li scolding Aroma for getting in Bao-yu’s good graces and not getting up to greet her when she came in the room. Nannie Li feels resentful at Aroma for taking her place, and Aroma is confused about Nannie Li’s scolding: She didn’t see Nannie Li because she was under the blankets sweating out her fever. Bao-yu interjects but causes more problems with Nannie Li and Aroma, until both women are crying. Finally, Xi-feng must distract his wet nurse and take her away into another room, and Dai-yu and Bao-chai laugh at Nannie Li’s wild rages. Bao-yu stays to care for Aroma for a bit, and then plays cards with his Grandmother Jia. He leaves early to check on Aroma, who is sleeping. Bored and unsure what to do, Bao-yu ends up spending time with another maid, Musk, and combing her hair. Another maid, Skybright, remarks his act is too romantic for an unmarried pair. She says, “Fancy! Doing her hair already—before you’ve even drunk the marriage cup” (405).
Because it’s the New Year’s holiday month, everyone is home and resting more than usual. Jia Huan, Bao-yu’s half-brother, is home as well, and he decides to go play cards with Bao-chai and her maid Oriole. But the more Jia Huan loses, the more upset he gets, until Bao-chai must smooth over the situation. Despite her best efforts, Jia Huan starts crying, and Bao-yu comes in at that moment and mocks him for not leaving if he isn’t enjoying himself. Jia Huan leaves and cries to his mother, who only scolds him further for spending time with the more prized children. Xi-feng overhears this and calls Jia Huan outside, reminding him that he can play with whoever he likes and giving him some more money to bet with.
Dai-yu was waiting in the hall when Bao-yu and Bao-chai came in, and she immediately became jealous that Bao-yu was spending time with Bao-chai, whom Dai-yu resented for her beauty and pleasant personality. Bao-yu tried to console Dai-yu, but she only sobbed through a few cups of tea. Finally, Bao-yu managed to remind her that she was his longest known friend and closest family, which comforted her slightly.
A visitor named Shi Xiang-yun, the great-niece of Grandmother Jia, then interrupts the game with Bao-yu and Bao-chai. Her arrival also distracts Dai-yu when Xiang-yun speaks to Dai-yu with her characteristic lisp. Dai-yun is in the habit of mocking her speech, but Xiang-yun mocks Dai-yu back, which begins a chase.
Bao-yu manages to stop the chase between Dai-yu and Xiang-yun by blocking the door. Xiang-yun stays in Dai-yu’s room that night, and the next morning, Bao-yu wakes up early, before Aroma, and spends the morning with the girls. He even does his morning washing in that room, which upsets Aroma, who is accustomed to their morning bathing ritual. This upset prompts Aroma to give Bao-yu the silent treatment, which then prompts Bao-yu to ignore both Aroma and Musk, who he thought were in cahoots with each other, and spend his day alone.
During this time, he reads from Zhuang-zi, which suggests, “Obliterate those ‘sacred laws’ by which the world is governed, and you will find yourself at last able to reason with them” (421). Bao-yu, whose world is governed by the appeal of women, writes his own version about ignoring Dai-yu, Bao-chai, Aroma, Musk, and all the other women in his life. The feud finally resolves the next morning, when Bao-yu finds Aroma in his bed but not under the covers, and she continues to ignore him. He admits he is worried about her, and Aroma gets to the heart of her complaint: “So you feel worried, do you [...] Now perhaps you have some idea what I feel like most of the time!” (425). Aroma forgives Bao-yu, and the two rise to do their washing.
In another part of the castle, Xi-feng’s baby daughter is diagnosed with small pox, and the family prepares a ritual for the Small Pox Goddess, including a red outfit for the baby, and the chastity of the parents during the 12-day incubation period. Jia Lian’s bedroom is moved into the outer office during this time, and after a few days, his sexual desires become overwhelming. He decides to seek out the services of a woman called “The Mattress,” who is known for giving sexual pleasure to all the men at the Ning-guo and Rong mansions. Jia Lian has an intimate encounter with “The Mattress,” calling her his only goddess after she brings up the Small Pox Goddess ritual.
After the 12 days are over and the baby heals, Patience cleans the room and finds a lock of “The Mattress’s” black hair behind the pillow. Jia Lian urges Patience to keep quiet so that Xi-feng doesn’t get jealous, and Patience’s anger at his infidelity causes him to desire her as well. Patience runs away just in time, as Xi-feng interrupts them and wonders at Patience’s strange behavior.
These chapters are particularly concerned with the idea of jealousy, ownership, and power, particularly among the women in the palace. The motif of fragrance also arises, in relation to Dai-yu, as a symbol of lust. Jealousy arrives primarily in the form of Dai-yu’s jealousy over Bao-yu’s relationship with Bao-chai in Chapter 20. Dai-yu becomes convinced that her outsider role in the family has made Bao-yu love Bao-chai more, though he reassures her that their long-time friendship makes her more precious to him than anyone else: “Old friends are best friends and close kin are kindest […] You’re too intelligent not to know that” (411).
Jealousy also arises in Nannie Li’s resentment of Aroma, also over her close relationship to Bao-yu. The rivalry between the higher-up female servants in the palace is a violent and uncontrollable one. Nannie Li berates Aroma for her insolence, though ultimately her anger stems more from her lack of self-worth since Bao-yu stopped suckling at her breast. For all the women in the family, including the servants, a close relationship with Bao-yu means more power. They are often jealous and vie for his attention to better their own lives.
The motif of perfume returns in Chapter 19 when Bao-yu becomes obsessed with a fragrance drifting from Dai-yu’s sleeve; he insistently asks her what it could be, and she says she isn’t wearing any perfume. The presence of the perfume in this scene symbolizes Bao-yu’s lust after Dai-yu as well as their fated attraction for one another; it signifies the cosmic influence of romance and lust, which bind the two throughout the novel. Bao-yu describes the fragrance as “subtle […] which […] caused one to feel rather limp” (394). Bao-yu’s physical lack of control over his own romantic feelings with one whiff of this fragrance is another indicator that the scent is from larger, more cosmic forces, over which Bao-yu has little to no control.