53 pages • 1 hour read
Colleen HooverA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
After having sex with Samson for the first time, Beyah wakes in the middle of the night to Samson saying, “I’m so sorry” (263). She watches a police officer handcuff him. A female officer tells her to get dressed and come downstairs. Downstairs, she sees the police take Samson outside. A man, a woman, and a small child enter and ask Beyah how she got into their house. Beyah insists it is Samson’s house, only to be told the house belongs to this couple; Samson will be charged with breaking and entering. Brian enters and tells the police Beyah had nothing to do with breaking into the house, and that he gave her permission to stay there the previous night. The police say that Beyah is not under arrest and can go home later but that they are taking her for questioning.
Seated with her father and two officers in an interrogation room, Beyah realizes there are many things she does not know about Samson. The police acknowledge she was not involved in any illegal activities. They leave the room to verify that Beyah can depart with her father. Beyah sees an addict in an outer room and knows that, in police custody, he will not receive help for his disease. She asks her father several questions about addiction. Her father asks if her mother is an addict, and she responds, “She’s not an addict anymore” (273). When the police return, they let Beyah go, but she wants to find out about Samson. Her father resists her efforts to discover what is happening with Samson, trying to keep the two apart. Beyah says that Samson is innocent and that he is a product of a system that failed him when he was only 13.
Arriving home from the police station, Beyah finds P. J. waiting, wagging his tail. As Beyah pets him, Sara comes down to console her and apologize for fixing her up with Samson. Beyah tells Sara that Samson is not a bad guy, that he has not done any grave harm, and that she doesn’t want to talk anymore.
Beyah receives a phone call from the Galveston County jail. Samson can talk to her for two minutes. She tells him she will not go to Pennsylvania because she wants to work to get him free. She tells him she will come to see him at nine the next day.
Beyah goes to Marjorie’s house and wakes her to tell her Samson has been arrested. She convinces Marjorie to call her son, an attorney, to ask him to represent Samson.
Beyah goes up to her room to go to sleep but finds she cannot rest. Searching for some kind of sleeping pill, she encounters Alana, who has taken the day off. For the first time, Beyah breaks down, sobbing, and Alana holds her as if she were her mother. Beyah wonders, “How long do I have to go before I’m happy again?” (288)
Beyah sleeps until seven that evening. She dumps out the contents of Samson’s backpack. She realizes that its contents are the only things Samson actually possesses. She finds a number of small, faded pieces of paper with writing on them. The papers turn out to be poems written by Rake.
The next morning, at the Galveston County jail, Beyah hears her name called to visit Samson, and she asks Brian to wait as she goes in by herself. She embraces Samson, and he apologizes. He fills in all the details of his life, explaining that his mother, Isabel, died when he was five and that Rake, his father, took him sailing up and down the Texas coast for years. Rake left him at a church during Hurricane Ike while he tried to protect the boat, and Samson never saw him again. As a juvenile, Samson made foolish mistakes and got in trouble with the law. He accidentally caused a house fire and realizes he will serve several years in the penitentiary. He tells Beyah he does not want her to make any more contact with him. He says, “You’re going to college, Beyah. My mess isn’t yours to clean up” (300).
Once back in the car, she and Brian argue about whether Samson is a worthy person. Beyah gets out of the car and refuses to ride home with him.
When a week passes with Samson refusing to allow Beyah to visit, she wonders if she will ever see him again. The only person she can talk to about Samson is Marjorie. Beyah discovers a small notebook with a list of every house he entered, every odd job he did, and all the food he ate. Beyah realizes Samson was keeping a list to make amends for entering people’s homes. She rushes downstairs to share this news with Brian, Alana, Sara, and Marcos. Beyah believes this is exculpatory and will help Samson’s case. Instead, Brian and Alana point out that these are additional crimes he could be charged with. Devastated by the lack of understanding she feels, Beyah thinks, “I know what love is, because I spent my whole life knowing what it isn’t” (311). She tells them her mother is dead. She explains she has been alone all of her life and even sold her body so she could buy food. Beyah says Brian has never been her father and never will be. Refusing to speak to him, she rushes to her room. In the little notebook she finds a note from Samson in which he tells her that she is his water and that she should flood the whole world.
Feeling abandoned, Beyah finds peace only by watching the sunrise. Brian comes onto the balcony and sits beside her. He asks if she remembers going to the beach as a little child. She has no memory of it until he brings an album and shows her all the things they did together when she was little. He apologizes for not having been there for her but says he believed he was an inconvenience to her. Beyah realizes she should have been more forthcoming with him about how she really felt. She thinks, “If there’s one thing I learned from Samson this summer, it’s that holding everything in accomplishes nothing. It just causes the truth to hurt even worse in the end” (319).
Brian asks her what Samson would want her to do if he truly loves her. Beyah realizes it is time to put herself first and that she must accept her scholarship to Penn State. For the first time she feels like she has a real family.
Living at Penn State in a dorm room, Beyah still does not hear from Samson, and the only news she gets of him is through regular conversations with Keith, Marjorie’s son and Samson’s attorney. She learns that Samson received a six-year sentence and that he might be paroled in four. She realizes he avoids contact because he wants her to live her life unconcerned about him.
Her roommate invites her to a party and offers to fix her makeup, which Beyah agrees to. She has decided she wants to be a fun person, even though that is something she may have to learn to do. She thinks, “I’m going to smile so much that my fake smile eventually becomes real” (329).
In October, four years later, Beyah waits outside the prison on the day Samson is scheduled for release. She is now a law student, after graduating from Penn State. She watches as Samson walks out of the institution and starts in the opposite direction. He pauses, then turns and stares at her. He shouts across the parking lot, asking if she went to college. When she nods, he runs toward her. They hold each other and kiss. He apologizes and she forgives him. He asks if she has a boyfriend, and she says she is single. Neither has any plans for what is to follow, though Samson asks if he can go to the sea. Beyah recites a line from a poem Rake wrote: “Because when a man says I’m going home, he should be headed for the sea” (337).
Beyah drives Samson to the beach where they first met. He immediately runs into the water. She sits with him after he comes out. He asks about P. J., Sara, Marcos, and Marjorie, who died in March. He says that he is supposed to call Keith to find out about his parole officer. Beyah gives him her phone to call Keith, who tells him that Marjorie willed her house to him because of all the good he did for those in the beach community. Overcome, Samson must walk away and compose himself. When he tells Beyah he does not deserve this, she replies, “You’ve been punished enough. Accept all the good things life is throwing at you today” (346). They go inside Marjorie’s house and climb to the roof, where they sit looking at the ocean, and they profess their love for each other.
In the final section of the narrative, Hoover returns to the major theme of Social, Financial, and Legal Inequality. To a much greater extent than any of the other characters, Beyah realizes that Samson, though he has made many mistakes, is a victim. From the time he was 13 years old, he was a destitute orphan with no institution or individual watching out for him. It was inevitable, she believes, that he was going to come up against legal restrictions. Though foolish, childish mistakes cost him his freedom, Beyah realizes he is not an unworthy person.
Hoover holds up the two main characters for readers to evaluate how each got to this point. While it is true that one is in prison and the other is going to a major university to pursue a new life, she makes clear that each experienced the same loss and the same resulting deprivation, such that the roles could have been reversed. Repeatedly, through Beyah, the author expresses the reality that people without resources can easily find themselves making the kinds of decisions that ruin their lives and even the lives of others. The novel supports the idea that in desperate times, people often make decisions to do things that are necessary, even if they are not right.
Beyah’s unfailing desire to help Samson, even though he does not want her help, draws her into the sharpest conflict yet with her father, stepsister, and stepmother. In a painful moment of isolation and misunderstanding, she confesses to her father that her mother is dead and that she was forced to prostitute herself in order to eat. While this has a profound impact on Brian, it is not something that Beyah wants to discuss. Once again, Beyah finds herself alone.
One of the most intimate scenes in the book takes place the morning after this revelation, when Brian shows Beyah photographs of herself as a little girl in places she had forgotten she had been, doing activities that she had mentally filed away. He explains that his assumption was that she found him to be an inconvenience. In that moment when the barriers between them are down, he presents her with a simple question that she must answer honestly, even though it causes her a great deal of pain: What does Samson want her to do? Realizing that she must go to Penn State and not stay in Texas, Beyah only asks if her father will take care of her dog.
In this sense, the third section of the narrative is concerned with sacrifices. Beyah must make the sacrifice of turning her back on someone she loves, leaving him in prison for years with no communication, while she learns to rejoice in living a happy life. Brian, who now has a daughter and has achieved a close relationship with her, must let her go away. Sara has the sister she always wanted and must say goodbye to her. The greatest sacrifice of all is Samson’s, who recognizes that, if he asks, Beyah would stay in Texas and wait for his release. Instead, he chooses the hell of not communicating with the one person he loves so that she can build her own life, with no assurances that he will ever see her again.
As is traditionally the case with romance novels, the story ends on a redemptive note, with Beyah and Samson reunited. Samson recoils at the realization of the gift of Marjorie’s house; as he says to Beyah, this is something he does not deserve. Beyah instead sees that here is someone who has suffered enough and should accept the good turn that life has to share with him at last. This parallels her own experience. At the beginning of the novel, she found herself staring at her mother’s dead body with no money, no future, and only resentment. Then fate brought her to her father’s home, where she encountered people who wanted to be a part of her life, and in particular Samson, who made her recognize that she was worthy. In this same way, now she is able to lift him up out of deprivation and reveal to him that there are those who recognize he is worthy.
By Colleen Hoover