34 pages • 1 hour read
William KennedyA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Dressed in a stolen kimono, Helen sings in her hotel room as she contemplates a painting of a swan that “was, was.” She reflects on her failed aspirations to become a classical pianist, which were cut short when her father committed suicide, leaving Helen’s mother to remove Helen from Vassar, a liberal arts school, in order to send Helen’s brother to law school.
The narrative goes back to the night before. In Finny’s car, Helen allows Finny to have sex with her, though he, exhausted, fails to ejaculate. Helen doesn’t sleep, instead getting lost in memory. In the morning, feeling pain from a tumor in her stomach, she hums “Te Deum” on her way to a nearby church that’s holding an All Saints’ Day service. A man in one of the pews reminds her of a classical conductor she once saw conducting Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony; excerpts from the text of the symphony’s final choral movement, based on Schiller’s “Ode to Joy,” are interspersed throughout the chapter.
Helen reflects on her relationship with her mother. After caring for her for a decade, Helen discovered a lost will leaving her half of her father’s inheritance 21 years too late. Helen abandoned her mother the same day, and her mother was transferred to a public nursing home, where she died. Helen also recalls her relationship with Arthur, a married man who owned a piano store where Helen worked in her twenties; the two carried on an affair until Arthur took up with another woman, and Helen found work elsewhere.
Leaving the church, Helen eats at a cheap cafeteria, paying with money hidden in her bra. She makes her way to a library, where she thinks back to her time living with Francis some eight years prior, until Francis lost his job as a handyman and started drinking again. Feeling nauseous, she leaves the library, then enters a music store on a whim. With the clerk’s permission, she samples recordings of Schubert lieder as well as the final movement of Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony, then she faints. After regaining consciousness, she leaves, taking the record with her under her shirt.
Fearing another collapse, she rents a room at Palombo’s Hotel, where she and Francis often stay, and she buys back a suitcase left there as collateral. In her room, she vomits, observes the painting of a swan, and rummages through her keepsakes. Sensing that she will soon die, she thinks back on her life mostly with satisfaction, questioning certain Catholic notions of sin and taking special pride in the fact that “she never betrayed anybody,” imagining her final separation from Francis as a way of setting him free (138). She dies peacefully as Beethoven’s music fuses with the naturalistic, Japanese imagery associated with her kimono.
A fire in a downtown warehouse causes a traffic jam, forcing Rosskam and Francis to change their route. As he works, Francis encounters the ghost of Fiddler Quain, a man who participated in the 1901 trolley strike at Francis’s bidding. A policeman struck Quain in the head, rendering him “mindless” until his death in 1913. Fiddler Quain suggests that Francis must find a way to forgive “those traitorous hands of yours” (143), leading Francis to reflect on his history of violence, including a time when he punished a “runt” who stole a bottle of soda from him by biting “a piece out of the back of his neck” (145).
As they approach the house where Francis’s wife and children live, Francis decides to stop working for the day so he can visit his family. After forcefully negotiating a payment for his work thus far, Francis buys a turkey, as he promised Billy the week before, then returns to his former home and knocks. Surprised and happy to see him, Annie invites him in. Francis recalls their first kiss in a lumberyard outside of the saloon where they met. Annie brings Francis up to date on family happenings and asks him why he came back; he struggles to articulate a reason, saying he just wants to see “the look of everybody” (162).
Danny, Francis’s 10-year-old grandson, arrives home, and Francis helps him with his pitching technique. Billy wakes up from a nap. He tells Francis that his standing in the town, recently lowered due to his involvement as an incidental witness to a political kidnapping case, has been restored, following the publication of a supportive newspaper article by Martin Daugherty, Katrina’s son.
Francis and Annie go through his things stored in the attic, including photos, newspaper clippings, and clothing; he gives Danny a bat signed by Ty Cobb. He then bathes and changes into clean clothes. Annie takes Francis into the backyard and invites him to stay permanently, insisting that he is “part of the family” (175). Meanwhile, Francis watches as ghosts from his past construct and sit in bleachers; he rebukes them. Later, he sees them holding candles and singing “Dies Irae.”
Peggy arrives and confronts Francis for his long absence; Billy comes to his defense. Francis tells Billy that he wants him to have his glove, and Billy is deeply moved. As they continue to talk, Peggy softens, and Francis shows her a letter she wrote to him as a child when he was away playing baseball, which he found in the attic. Her husband, George Quinn, who has been staying elsewhere for reasons connected to Billy’s political scandal, arrives, and they all sit down for dinner.
Chapter 5 opens as it ends: in Helen’s hotel room moments before her death. Here, the circular narrative structure not only offers a window into Helen’s thoughts, as it did earlier for Francis, but also lends the chapter a sense of wholeness or arrival suitable to Helen’s preparation for a dignified death. Indeed, Helen surrounds herself with many of the things she loves: music, art, clothing, and tokens from her life. Her fascination with the painted swan that “was, was” reveals, perhaps, a nostalgic longing for things to remain as they are or were. Even with the end in sight, this becomes a moment of celebration rather than mourning, as she revisits Beethoven’s Ode to Joy.
On the other hand, Helen doesn’t deny the difficult aspects of her life and recent experience. Within the last 24 hours of her life, she exchanges sex for shelter and grapples with significant religious concerns. She recalls the major relationships of her life, not all of which ended well. Before dying, however, she manages to view her choices not as “sins” in need of confession but as “decisions,” the most important of which is her decision to remain loyal to her loved ones (138). Acknowledging her own autonomy, as well as the key values that drove her to act as she did, provides her with a measure of peace, and she drifts away. In this instance, she differs from Francis, who occasionally feels as though his hands have a will of their own, particularly during violent outbursts.
Francis’s brief time spent at his former home, if not quite a portrait of domestic bliss, certainly presents a sharp contrast with his life in the streets. Apart from his initially cool reception from Peggy, his family makes it clear that he is welcome there, but Francis hesitates, demonstrating that the primary barriers to his return to such a life are, and always have been, internal—a mixture of guilt, unworthiness, flightiness, and some residual responsibility toward Helen.
Francis’s simultaneous confrontation with the crowd of ghosts who assemble in his yard constitutes a climax of sorts: he rejects them for being unreal and, therefore, irrelevant. No matter how valid their claims may have been in life, the needs of the living take precedence. This constitutes an epiphany on Francis’s part and opens the way for him to move forward without fear. Though the ghosts do not vanish immediately, their singing “Dies Irae,” a song that heralds judgment day in Christian theology, suggests that their time may be up.