49 pages • 1 hour read
Zane GreyA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In light of Fay’s disappearance, Jane says that she will give in, and that she’ll go to Tull and agree to marry him. Lassiter refuses to allow her. Instead, he gets his guns and tells Jane to have the horses packed and ready to go when he comes back. Jane argues with Lassiter, trying to convince him not to turn to violence. Lassiter explains this isn’t about revenge for his sister, but to avenge Jane. However, Jane doesn’t want the death of Dyer on her conscience. She tells Lassiter she loves him, and she’ll go away with him if he promises not to hurt anyone, but he continues to argue that this is the only way. Finally, Jane tells Lassiter the truth: Her father was the Mormon proselytizer who preached to Milly Erne. Jane also says that her father was likely the father of Milly’s child as well as Fay’s father. Jane understands that her father was not a good man and says that he is likely meeting his punishment in the afterlife. Lassiter brushes her off still, insisting that he is not going after Dyer for Milly’s sake, and Jane faints.
When Jane wakes, Judkins is with her. Judkins tells Jane that Lassiter found Dyer and shot him. Tull, however, was out of town and Lassiter was unable to harm him. Lassiter asks Judkins to ride Jane out into the sage and tells him to shoot anyone they might see. Jane rides out, and when Lassiter joins her, he tells her not to look back. They race into the sage and toward Deception Pass. Jane never looks back but becomes aware of a large cloud of smoke from her burning home.
Venters and Bess pack to leave Surprise Valley. As they leave the canyon, they run into Lassiter and Jane. Lassiter expresses pleasure at having run into them, but as he says this, Jane realizes that Venters’s companion is a woman. Jane becomes upset and vents all her frustrations on Venters. When she calms down, she asks about Bess, learning that Bess is the daughter of Oldring. Jane wonders aloud how Bess could go away with the man who killed her father.
Bess becomes upset, insisting she must go back to the rustlers because it is her duty as Oldring’s daughter to do so. Venters argues against it, but Bess is determined until Lassiter shows her a locket and asks if she knows the woman whose picture is inside. When Bess says the eyes are familiar, Lassiter tells her that Milly Erne and her husband, Frank, are Bess’s real parents and her name is Elizabeth Erne. He explains that Oldring told him he was paid by Dyer to keep Bess and to turn her into a feared rustler in order to torture Milly with the life her child has embraced. Oldring made Bess his masked rider, but he secretly fell in love with her, so he also taught her to read and protected her from the darkest parts of the rustler lifestyle. Oldring claimed he intended to return Bess to her father upon Dyer’s death. Lassiter’s information frees Bess to continue traveling with Venters, and it softens Jane toward her as she realizes Bess is her half-sister and the child of her friend.
Lassiter suggests they all go back to Surprise Valley and hide until they can decide what to do next. Venters refuses, however, determined to marry Bess and give her a better life. Jane and Lassiter decide to give Venters and Bess Night and Black Star because there is no way they can escape Tull on burros. Lassiter instructs Venters to go north following a trail that bypasses the villages.
Almost immediately as they enter the sage, Venters and Bess see riders in the distance. Venters instructs Bess to go north, then cut to the west. He encourages her to ride fast and not to worry about where he is. They are soon spotted by Tull and his men and begin to run. Venters remembers that she was Oldring’s masked rider, and the rumors of her riding skills were not exaggerated. They easily outrun Tull and his men.
Bess and Venters stop to rest, and Bess extols the virtues of the horses. They continue on, and they decide to return to Surprise Valley in 10 years. Venters tells Bess they will rest for a while before continuing on to Sterling. He says they’ll be married in Sterling and take the stagecoach to Illinois. Venters believes he hears a deep rumble, but Bess doesn’t, so he lets it go.
Lassiter and Jane descend into Deception Pass. When they reach a junction, Lassiter leaves Jane while he goes to scout ahead. He returns and tells Jane he has found some men he was looking for, and that she should stay and wait. He slips away and after a short time, Jane hears gunfire. She listens and realizes she no longer feels the strong objection to it she once felt. Lassiter returns with several injuries, including a bullet wound in his hand. Lassiter explains that he went after the men because they had Fay. She fell during the struggle, but Lassiter believes she will be okay.
Lassiter urges Jane to hurry up the canyon toward Surprise Valley. They can see riders coming after them and assume it is Tull. Lassiter has used all his ammunition, so they must get to Surprise Valley before Tull catches up to them. They ride as quickly as they can and get ahead of Tull and his men, but the horse is worn out and collapses. They continue on foot, carrying two saddle bags and Fay. Lassiter leaves his guns behind. Finally, they reach the carved steps that lead up to Surprise Valley. When they reach the stone at the entrance, Lassiter pauses. He tells Jane that the stone will seal them in forever, but he won’t do it if Jane doesn’t want to be with him. Tull can be seen coming up the steps. Jane tells Lassiter that she loves him and asks him to roll the stone. He does, sealing them inside Surprise Valley forever.
Her father’s immoral behavior fuels Jane’s friendships with non-Mormon people and her refusal of Tull’s proposal. It is not the Mormon faith Jane has lost faith in—it is the actions of Mormon men, touching once more on the theme of Gender Dominance and Dynamics. While Jane, as an orphan, would normally be unable to deny the dominance of her church leaders, her father’s wealth places her in a position to do so despite the fact that her father dominated her as well, keeping her quiet about his actions.
The death of Dyer is the second of three deaths that comprise the climax of the plot. While Dyer’s death doesn’t solve Jane’s situation, it does stop him from continuing to create victims of other women. Dyer’s death leaves Jane with an altered view of Lassiter’s actions, making it difficult for her to offer a prayer of remorse and hope for Dyer’s soul. This is a change that foreshadows Jane’s continued change of view on violence as the novel progresses.
Lassiter and Jane run into Venters and Bess as they run away, and more truths are revealed. The idea that Bess might be Milly’s daughter has been foreshadowed throughout the novel. In learning that Bess is Milly’s daughter, Venters is freed of his guilt for killing Bess’s father, and this removes the last impediment to their relationship. Jane now knows her other half-sister is alive and safe, and that allows her to put aside her anger with Venters for hiding her. Finally, Lassiter now knows that something good has come out of his 18 years of seeking revenge for his sister.
The revelation of Bess being Milly’s daughter also illustrates the theme of Morality Versus Virtue Signaling, as it contrasts the morality of a cattle rustler like Oldring to Tull, Dyer, and Jane’s father, active elders within the Mormon church. While someone might assume Oldring, a man who has a reputation for theft, rape, and murder, might not have strong morals, it is revealed that Tull, Dyer, and Jane’s father were behind the dominance, rape, kidnapping, and theft against many women.
Jane’s views on violence have motivated her actions from the beginning of the novel. Jane set out to seduce Lassiter to stop him from killing Mormons, and she encouraged Venters and her riders not to carry guns. Yet, after the death of Dyer, her view is altered. When Lassiter goes to get Fay back from the rustlers, Jane is not bothered by the sounds of the guns like she once was. When it comes time to push over the rock that blocks the entrance to Surprise Valley, Jane doesn’t hesitate to encourage Lassiter to do it, despite the fact that Tull will be killed in the resulting landslide. This change is attributed to Jane’s acceptance that there are occasions when violence is the only solution to a problem. The pushing over of the rock outside Surprise Valley has been foreshadowed since the moment Venters recognized its purpose. It signals the collapse of Jane’s Mormon faith along with the collapse of the novel’s Religious Conflict.
Action & Adventure
View Collection
American Literature
View Collection
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Pride & Shame
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Revenge
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Westerns
View Collection