43 pages • 1 hour read
McCall HoyleA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Stella, a beagle, wakes up in a metal crate eager to check out all the smells in the world. She wants to be with her old handler, Connie, whom she worked with at an airport. One day when she was working with Connie, Stella smelled a chemical and then an ambulance took Connie away. Stella knows Connie would never voluntarily leave her, but she doesn’t know that Connie died. Stella lives with a new human now, Diana. Stella tries to be a good dog for Diana, but she starts to panic when a storm rolls in. She begins digging and panting and eventually using her teeth to tear the pad at the bottom of her crate. Stella remembers Connie telling her that she is a good dog, and she still believes that. Diana wakes up and tells Stella that she is a bad dog. This does not make sense to Stella because Connie yelled at her once for running in front of a truck, but ripping a pad is not as bad as that. Diana takes her outside, and Stella thinks that Diana must have made a mistake because she left her with no food.
Stella is still outside. Diana gives her some food but otherwise doesn’t pay her any attention. On day three of being outside, Stella starts to bark, bay, and dig. Diana brings Stella back inside, and Stella lies at the feet of Diana’s friend. Diana explains to the man that Stella would be great if she had someone home with her all day, but she acts out when Diana leaves or when she hears loud noises. Stella thinks humans are confusing. Stella knows some words, but sometimes a person’s words do not match the smell of their feelings. Diana goes on to explain to her friend that Stella was injured in an airport explosion. Diana believes Stella needs to live in the country with children, and she tells the man that she cannot keep Stella. She tells Stella that she is a good dog, but her voice sounds sad.
That night Stella sleeps on the floor next to Diana’s bed, and the next day they go for a ride in the car. Diana apologizes to Stella for having to return her, but Stella smells the city and believes she is going to be reunited with Connie. She recognizes the canine facility they drive up to, which makes her excited because she thinks it means that Diana will find her own dog, and Stella can go live with Connie again.
Stella smells Jake and Ava in the facility but she only catches the slightest scent of Connie. She wonders why everyone sounds sad. Ava tells Diana that they feared Stella would not make it because of the trauma she suffered. Diana cries as she leaves, and Stella wishes she could help her. She knows, however, that she belongs with Connie and that Diana will find the perfect dog for her. Stella picks up Connie’s scent, but it is old; Connie has not been in the building in quite a while. Stella sees Doc Collins. He smells anxious, which is uncommon for him. Jake takes Stella and cuddles with her, and Stella knows that something is wrong because Jake never does this. Jake tells Stella that they are going to put her out of her misery as an act of kindness. He tells her that she is a good girl, but Stella does not believe this because if she were good, Connie would be here with her. She would have been able to alert Connie to the chemicals she smelled in the airport and would not have been distracted by the air coming in through the doors. Stella knows that humans put dogs out of their misery by putting them into a deep sleep. Stella licks Jake’s hand and hopes he will change his mind. She will not make any more mistakes. She knows she will not see Connie again if they put her out of her misery.
Stella does not believe Doc Collins will let her be put to sleep. He comes in with a woman named Esperanza. She has come to help them select which dogs should be a part of their explosion detection program. Esperanza believes she might be able to help Stella. Jake does not think this is fair to Stella because they have already tried three different homes for Stella and none of them worked. Esperanza was a friend of Connie’s, and she wants to help Stella for Connie’s sake.
Esperanza holds Stella, and Stella likes her calm breathing and heartbeat. Stella and Esperanza go in the woman’s car, and Stella is overwhelmed by the scent of flowers. Stella does not know if she should be happy that she is still alive or sad that they are leaving Connie farther behind. Esperanza says that they are going to say goodbye to Connie. They arrive at a cemetery, and Stella sniffs around. Stella recognizes the smell of dead human bodies because of a time she helped Connie find a man in a ditch. She gets confused because she smells Connie, but it is not all of Connie. Rather, she smells the “shell” of Connie. She finds Connie’s grave and stands on top of it at high alert. Esperanza tells Stella that it is time for her to move on. She wants to tell Esperanza to do something to help find Connie. Stella realizes, however, that Connie is gone because of the mistake Stella made. This makes her believe that she is a bad dog and always will be.
As a dog, Stella has a difficult time understanding all aspects of human behavior. She bases her opinions about herself on how her humans treat her, and because different handlers react to her differently, she gets confused about whether or not she is a good dog. For example, in Chapter 1 she gets confused over the different reactions Connie and Dianna have to her behavior. She remembers being yelled at by Connie for running in front of a truck. This yelling makes sense because what she did was dangerous. Diana yells at her, however, for chewing up a pad, which Stella knows is a much less serious offense. Stella is already confused because of the trauma she experienced at the airport. Inconsistent human reactions do not help stop her confusion. It therefore becomes important for Stella to be with handlers who understand dogs and know how to communicate with them.
Because dogs and humans do not share a language, humans have to find other ways to understand dogs in order to meet their needs. Diana cannot understand Stella, not because she is a bad person but because they aren’t a good fit. Diana herself admits that Stella needs someone with her at all times, which Diana is unable to do. She is also unable to comfort Stella at night and at other times when she is afraid. The Bond Between Humans and Animals relies on many factors, and just because a dog does not work well with a specific human does mean that either the dog or the person is bad. This creates nuance in the novel as it shows that people and animals can be both imperfect and good at the same time.
Stella also has difficulty understanding the world around her. She doesn’t understand what happened with Connie at the airport and the reason why they are separated. She knows that she made a mistake, but she still believes that Connie is out there somewhere and hopes they can be reunited. She does understand that there is a difference between being alive and dead: For her, death means that a person or an animal becomes a “shell.” Her understanding of death suggests that she was likely taken away from Connie before Connie actually died. In order to be able to move on, Stella will have to understand what happened to Connie, and she cannot do this alone.
Putting a suffering animal to sleep is shown to be an act of mercy, as can be seen through the character of Jake. He is physically affectionate toward Stella as they wait for Doc Collins to come in. He believes that Stella is suffering beyond anyone’s ability to help her and is skeptical when Esperanza offers to help. Jake thinks another attempt to rehome Stella is likely to fail and thus is not fair to the dog. He does not doubt Esperanza’s abilities, but he does think that Stella has been through enough trauma.
Stella makes her first step in her healing journey when she goes to the cemetery with Esperanza and smells Connie’s “shell.” At first, she wants Esperanza to help Connie, but she comes to understand that Connie is dead, and she further realizes that her mistake at the airport caused Connie’s death. While this realization helps Stella understand that she cannot go back to Connie, it also sets her back emotionally. Because her mistake harmed someone she loved, she believes she is a bad dog. Learning that Connie has died helps her move on from her old life, but she still has a lot of work to do to achieve Forgiveness and Grace.
Animals in Literature
View Collection
Books that Teach Empathy
View Collection
Coping with Death
View Collection
Disability
View Collection
Fiction with Strong Female Protagonists
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (Middle Grade)
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection