63 pages • 2 hours read
Susan OrleanA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The first book burning recorded by history occurred in 213 BCE. Chinese emperor Qin Shi Huang burned any book that challenged or disagreed with his version of historical events. He also burned over 400 scholars alive. The most notorious library burning was that of the Library of Alexandria, which was burned down a few times. The first time was when Julius Caesar invaded the Port of Alexandria in 48 BCE. He only intended to attack the port, but the fire spread to the library. The Egyptian people restored the library and restocked its volumes. It was burned twice more, but the people always restored it. Unfortunately, it was burned for a final and decisive time in 640 CE. Caliph Omar destroyed the library based on the assumption that all of its books either “contradicted the Koran” or supported it, which made the books “redundant” (95). The library burned for six months until it was completely incinerated. The invaders took the few books that survived and used them as fuel for bathhouses. Some theories about the destruction of the Library of Alexandria challenge the primary narrative about arson. Some think that earthquakes and even a reduced financial budget may have caused its failure.
In 13th- and 14th-century Europe, the Catholic pope ordered that all Jewish texts be “cremated” (96). His reasoning was that the texts were anti-Catholic. Book burnings were common during the Spanish Inquisition. When the Spanish arrived in the Americas, they continued their book burnings, contending that Aztec manuscripts contained recipes for witchcraft. They also burned Mayan books. A few Mayan texts have survived and are the only surviving documents from the Mayan civilization.
Many libraries have been lost throughout history. According to UNESCO, billions have been destroyed. The biggest culprit of library destruction was war. During the Third Reich, the Nazis destroyed around 100,000,000 books. Soon after he became chancellor of the Reichstag, Adolf Hitler banned all publications that he deemed “subversive”—all of them were books by Jewish and left-wing authors (97). On May 10, 1933, The Nazis burned thousands of banned books under the direction of Joseph Goebbels in Berlin’s Opera Square. Members of the German Student Union gathered in the square, “formed a human chain, passed the books from hand to hand” and threw them into a bonfire (97). As they destroyed the books, they declared why each one was “sentenced to death” (98). The works of Sigmund Freud, for example, “were charged with spiritual corruption” (98). The book burnings also took place in Munich, Frankfurt, and other major German cities. There were over 30 the following year.
The Nazis also employed “Brenn-Kommandos,” or “book-burning squads,” who burned down libraries and synagogues (99). They destroyed all Czech-language biographies and books about geography and history. In Vilnius, Lithuania, a squad set the library in a Jewish ghetto on fire. Similar burnings continued in other cities, including Budapest and Kiev. The book losses in Germany were most shocking. By 1945, more than a third of all of Germany’s books were incinerated. In 1954, the Hague Convention took steps to ensure that such devastation would never occur again. One hundred and twenty-seven countries signed and adopted the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict. This, however, didn’t stop further destruction of books. In China, Mao Tse-tung—a former librarian—became a book burner. He demanded that all books that offended him be destroyed. He then sent the Red Guard to Tibet to cleanse Tibetan libraries.
In Cambodia, during the 1970s, the Khmer Rouge burned all but 20% of the books from the Cambodian National Library. More recently, the Iraqi army burned most of Kuwait’s libraries during its 1990 invasion of that country and 200 libraries burned down during the Bosnian War. In Afghanistan, the Taliban destroyed 15 out of 18 libraries. During the second war in Iraq, all but 30% of the Iraqi National Library’s books were destroyed. The remaining books survived either because Saddam Hussein kept them for his private collection or Iraqis hid them out of fear that they would be destroyed in the war.
In the United States, book burnings were the results of attempts to ban content. Comic books came under fire in the 1940s due to their depictions of crime and sex. Soon after the Second World War, 30-year-old Ray Bradbury started work on a story that he first called “The Fireman,” which was set in a future dystopian society that banned books. The firemen in Bradbury’s story were like the Brenn-Kommandos—they started fires. Bradbury was from Los Angeles and wrote fantasy and science fiction stories since his teen years. He also used the library to educate himself instead of attending college. Bradbury worked on the story for a while, got writer’s block, and put it aside. He returned to the project after listening to an inflammatory speech by Senator Joseph McCarthy which claimed that the State Department was full of Communist traitors. Bradbury used the basement of UCLA’s Powell Library to finish his story, which became Fahrenheit 451—named for the temperature at which paper burned. When Central Library burned in 1986, all of the books from A through L in its Fiction section burned, including Bradbury’s.
There are around 200 libraries fires per year in the U.S. Most are the results of mundane accidents involving dysfunctional coffeepots and short circuits. Sometimes they result from casual vandalism, such as someone throwing a lit match into a book return slot. This is why most book drops are now outside of a library’s main building. Los Angeles is also prone to fires, including arsons. Five thousand and four hundred of them were reported in LA in 1986. A Glendale fire captain named John Leonard Orr wrote a book about arson cases—Points of Origin. Orr’s colleagues became suspicious of him. Real-life arsons closely resembled those in Orr’s book. Authorities later found Orr’s fingerprint at the scene of an arson crime. Orr was later found guilty for “twenty counts of arson and four counts of murder” (107). He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. After he was imprisoned, the number of brush fires in and around Glendale declined by 90%. Other libraries have burned in Los Angeles, including the Hollywood Branch Library, which was destroyed by arson in 1982. Central Library also went up in flames again twice more after its 1986 fire.
Arin Kasparian was a server at Subway when he applied for a job at the library to please his concerned mother. Kasparian was in his mid-twenties when Orlean met him and said that he was happy that he made the decision to apply at the library. He planned to become a children’s and young adult librarian. In 1997, library school administrators noticed that applicants were becoming younger, more diverse, and many of them were male. Part of the appeal lies in salary and benefits. Librarians make good money, particularly in larger systems, such as that in Los Angeles, where entry-level salaries start at over $60,000. There is now even a comic-book series about a librarian based on the life of Seattle-based librarian Nancy Pearl. Similarly, Nelson Torres, another employee, had never been much of a reader. He took a job at the library while in high school and has remained since. Kasparian told Orlean that, when he first saw homeless people in the library, he was afraid of them. Now, he knows many of them. It makes him feel good that he can serve them, too.
When Central Library closed, no plans were set for its reopening. Insurance covered some of the repair costs. The estimated cost of replacing the destroyed books, periodicals, and patent collection was $14 million. The cost of restoring damaged books was still unknown. What everyone did know was that the funds didn’t exist. Additionally, Jones noted that many of those books that were destroyed were out of print or had to be ordered from 700 different sellers.
Lodwrick Cook, the head of ARCO, cochaired the “Save the Books” campaign to raise funds to replace lost books. Cook also offered Jones and his administrative staff ARCO’s offices as workspace. The librarians, accustomed to operating on a narrow budget, was “awed by the luxury of ARCO’s offices,” while the ARCO staff found the librarians sophisticated and learned (116). ARCO also provided the campaign with $500,000. Other donations soon came in from the J. Paul Getty Trust, best-selling author Sidney Sheldon, and Dr. Seuss. Some donations came in the form of book volumes and sets. Louis L’Amour’s widow donated her husband’s complete works and the estate of Edgar Rice Burroughs donated many of the author’s works. Actor Charlton Heston hosted a cocktail party to raise funds. The cause drew the city together.
One day, someone had the idea of putting on a telethon to raise funds. Gene Scott, the pastor of the Pentecostal Westcott Christian Center, offered to host the event in his church’s enormous auditorium. Scott had a large audience. The monetary goal for the fundraiser was $2 million. Celebrities participated and read passages from their favorite books. In the end, the telethon exceeded its goal.
Los Angeles established its first public library in 1844. It started as a reading room at a social club called Amigos del País. When the social club became indebted, the reading room closed, but the town’s interest in having a reading space persisted. In 1872, an association worked toward opening a library. One of the association’s members, John Downey, donated space in a building he owned called the Downey Block. Its outdoor area was reserved for the auctions of indigenous people. The library opened to the public in January 1873, but membership came with a five-dollar fee. This limited the space to the rich. Also, no children were permitted to enter. Though the library was popular, some people worried that having so many people in a small enclosed space would lead to the spread of disease. Influenza, smallpox, and typhus were rampant at the time.
The city’s first librarian was a sickly asthmatic named John Littlefield, whose smoking bothered patrons. His successor, Patrick Connolly, was an alcoholic painter whose tenure only lasted for a year. Mary Foy, an 18-year-old young woman, was hired as Connolly’s replacement. This was at a time when libraries did not permit women to have library cards and they were only allowed to occupy the Ladies’ Room. No other library in the nation had a female head librarian. Only 25% of all library staff members were women.
Foy was a serious and effective administrator. However, “when the mayor who appointed her left office in 1884, the library board voted to remove her” (126). They claimed that she no longer needed to work, now that her father made enough money to care for her needs. Her successor, Jessie Gavitt, quietly ran the library, as did her successor Lydia Prescott. Then, in 1889, Tessa Kelso, an Ohio-bred newspaper reporter, was appointed to the position of head librarian. Kelso was single, smoked cigarettes, and had no experience working in libraries. She came in wanting to modernize the library. She wanted it to serve as a place where people could be entertained and educated. Kelso raised the number of library cardholders to 20,000. She also allowed children over the age of 12 to use the library, as long as they maintained good school grades. She ensured that immigrants and rural areas were served and moved the library to a more spacious building in the new City Hall.
Kelso’s lack of training with libraries encouraged her to seek highly-trained staff members. She hired Adelaide Hass, a champion bicycle racer. Together, they established one of the first library schools on the West Coast. She also expanded the library’s collection to 300,000 books. Kelso came under fire, however, when she ordered a controversial volume—Le Cadet by French author Jean Richepin. Methodist minister Reverend J. W. Campbell started a public vigil for her soul. In response, Kelso sued him. Kelso argued that she wasn’t responsible for the controversial book selection. The book committee approved all new acquisitions. She also maintained that acquiring the book reflected her right to free speech. Kelso won the suit, but public opinion and the library board were now against her. Kelso then sued the city for not reimbursing her for past travel expenses. The city gave her the money, then asked her to leave her position. Kelso resisted at first, but eventually relented.
New head librarians included Clara Bell Fowler and Harriet Child Wadleigh who tried to move the library to a bigger space, but there were no funds to make that happen. Meanwhile, the city’s population continued to expand, meaning that the library had more patrons. When Wadleigh’s husband struck gold in their backyard, she left the library and was replaced by Mary Letitia Jones, the first city librarian who graduated from a library school. Jones was “serious, efficient, and innovative” (129). She also allowed children as young as 10 to enter. She hired African American librarians to serve in neighborhoods with large black populations. Finally, she increased circulation to 400,000 books annually.
Around this time, philanthropist Andrew Carnegie launched a project in 1890 in which he committed to building libraries around the country. He recalled how, during his boyhood, he was disappointed that he couldn’t afford library dues. He decided that he would fund the construction of free libraries in communities that would agree to continue to support them through tax revenues. In 1905, the head of the library board, Isidore Dockweiler, asked Jones to resign, saying that the library would be better served by a male librarian. Jones resisted and got the support of 1,000 women who signed a petition in support of her. Jones eventually gave in and left Los Angeles to take a position as head librarian at the Seven Sisters women’s college Bryn Mawr. Dockweiler chose the journalist and adventurer Charles Fletcher Lummis to succeed Jones. Even in the 19th century, Jones’s firing was a surprise because women ran most of the nation’s libraries. However, the women were offered lower pay, regardless of their level of education.
Lummis arrived in Los Angeles in 1885 to take a position as a journalist for the Los Angeles Times. He was a reporter in Ohio and decided to walk cross-country to his new post. Lummis was born in Lynn, Massachusetts in 1859 to a widower father who was a stern Methodist minister. He attended Harvard where he befriended Theodore Roosevelt. He was a poor student but excelled in sports and card-playing. He was also known as “the man with the longest hair on campus” (133). He eventually dropped out to write for newspapers. Lummis married instead, but still read and wrote a lot. He had a preference for poetry and printed his own book of poems on birch bark. The book that resulted, Birch Bark Poems, was praised by both Walt Whitman and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and sold thousands of copies.
Lummis was an eccentric dresser and a self-promoter. He decided to walk across the country to get to know the nation better. Before leaving his home state, he convinced a local newspaper to print his travel diary, which he would write as a weekly letter. Lummis walked 30 miles each day and wrote about what he saw or did during his walks. He described meeting real cowboys and learning about indigenous cultures. He recounted being robbed by hoboes in Missouri and trekking through mountains in New Mexico. There were instances in which he risked starvation and was deprived of water. He picked up a companion in Colorado—“an abandoned greyhound puppy that he named Shadow” (135). Tragically, the dog got rabies and Lummis had to shoot him. Other newspapers picked up Lummis’s column. Sometimes when he entered towns, crowds arrived to greet him. By the time he arrived in Los Angeles, he was a celebrity.
Using Fahrenheit 451 as an allegorical signpost, Orlean describes how books have been destroyed throughout history, both for careless and methodical reasons, including committing arson as a means of achieving fame. The story of John Leonard Orr provides some context to what we later learn about Harry Peak. Orr destroyed to provide himself with inspiration to create. He used his arsons as fodder for the books that made him famous. It is unclear and probably unlikely that Peak committed the Central Library fire, but he was willing to destroy his reputation—asserting to some friends that he was a possible criminal—in exchange for fame and attention, due to his inability to succeed as an actor. Peak longed for the aura of exclusivity that Hollywood emblematizes and that the earliest libraries also engendered. Ironically, in their first iterations in the mid-1800s, libraries were both exclusive spaces and spaces that harbored diseases, which staff members at the time were ill-equipped to manage or prevent. In contrast, today’s librarians take workshops on how to detect contagious diseases, such as Tuberculosis, and infestations, such as lice.
Books & Literature
View Collection
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
#CommonReads 2020
View Collection
Common Reads: Freshman Year Reading
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Reese Witherspoon's Hello Sunshine...
View Collection
True Crime & Legal
View Collection