87 pages • 2 hours read
Matt de la PeñaA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Shy wakes to find his roommate, Rodney, standing over his bed. Rodney is a six-foot-four offensive lineman who works as an assistant to the head chef; Shy describes him as “an enthusiastic hugger who didn’t understand his own strength” (13). Today is Rodney’s 19th birthday, and he and Shy make their way to the crew level of the ship for a celebration. Shy is momentarily distracted by “plenty of fresh female faces to scope out—Shy’s favorite pastime” (16), but his friend Carmen quickly becomes the focus of his attention. Carmen is a beautiful 18-year-old Mexican American woman whom Shy is unable to look away from, despite the fact that he knows she has a fiancé waiting for her at home.
Shy remembers a basketball game he once attended with his family, where he won a $2,000 check for making a series of difficult shots. This memory is one of his happiest, but it also reminds him of the way he views his place in the world: “Because nothing like this was supposed to happen to some anonymous kid like him. He was just a dude from down by the border. Didn’t they know?” (17). As he returns from this memory, he wonders whether he’ll ever be able to laugh again, worrying that “seeing a guide fall from the ship had sort of messed something up in his head” (17).
Shy, Carmen, Rodney, and their two other friends—Kevin, an Australian underwear model, and Marcus, a hip-hop dancer—gather to celebrate Rodney’s birthday over pizza. Aside from Rodney, Shy thinks that “pretty much everyone on the crew” is attractive and reflects on the fact that the girls in his hometown used to call him “pretty boy” (21). The five crewmates discuss David Williamson’s death, and Kevin tells Shy that they need to talk because he wants to warn Shy about something.
Shy and Kevin leave to go lock up the pool on the Lido Deck, where they meet Dr. Christian, a recent medical school graduate. Once Shy and Kevin are alone, Kevin says that a man in a black suit—who turns out to be named Bill—has been asking about Shy with relation to David Williamson’s suicide and pressuring the head of security for information about him. As they finish putting away the pool equipment, Kevin notices that the man in the black suit has been watching them this whole time. Shy and Kevin are both unnerved, and Kevin promises to stay with Shy until he heads back to his cabin.
Shy retires to his cabin and attempts to sleep, but his anxiety keeps him awake. He has vivid, nightmare-like visions of the man in the black suit breaking into his room to slit his throat with a machete, then of David Williamson dragging him off the ship and into the ocean. Finally, he remembers the bloody death of his grandmother, which he witnessed through the glass of her quarantine room. His grandmother died of Romero, an extremely painful and lethal disease that has recently developed into an epidemic in Mexico and the states that line the southern border of the United States.
Shy eventually gives up trying to sleep. He receives an email from his mother asking to Skype the next day, as she has “some possibly worrisome news she’d rather not share over email” (30). The email, on top of the stress from David’s suicide, Bill following him around the ship, and his resurfacing memories of his grandmother, begins to weigh heavily on Shy, and he leaves his cabin to “wander the halls and think” (30). He thinks about the difference between his life and the lives of the premier class passengers and imagines what it might be like to be so rich and successful. He finds himself standing on the deck where David killed himself, looking out at the water and feeling “incredibly alone. A tiny, insignificant human” (31). The sheer scale of the ocean and his comparative insignificance is overwhelming, and he sympathizes with David as “for a split second he understood how someone could be moved to jump” (31).
Eventually, Shy arrives at Carmen’s cabin and hesitates outside, wanting to see her but not wanting to wake her up at three in the morning. He and Carmen have been close friends since their first voyage: “They realized they were from the same area, went to rival high schools—though Carmen had just graduated. Then they discovered something else they had in common. Romero Disease” (33). Shy’s grandmother and Carmen’s father both died of Romero Disease, and this knowledge combined with their solidarity against the rich and self-centered passengers helps create a strong bond between the two. Carmen and Shy share a bottle of wine and talk about their families, then about Carmen’s fiancé—whom Shy is trying hard not to be jealous of—and then of David’s suicide again. As Shy and Carmen get drunker, Shy starts talking about space and the idea that there might be another version of their lives where they are together. He explains:
I think on one of those faraway planets there’s a space version of me and there’s a space version of you. And I bet our space versions met earlier in life. In junior high. On the swings at the park or something. And they probably hit it off in about two point five. Like love at first sight or whatever. And since that day they’ve been all about each other (41).
Shy and Carmen hold hands to “find out if their space versions are compatible” (41), and soon Carmen kisses him. They continue kissing until Carmen stops and turns away, upset, and Shy fears that “he’d messed up everything with the only girl who understood” (45).
Shy feels a great deal of guilt over the deaths of David Williamson and his grandmother. He feels responsible for his failure to save David Williamson, and he fears that he has abandoned his family when they needed him most, right after the death of his grandmother. He is clearly traumatized after witnessing these deaths; he “hardly slept the night before. Or the night before that. Or the night before” (12), and he sees David’s suicide and his grandmother’s violent death “every time” he closes his eyes. When the man in the black suit begins following him around the ship, Shy fears that he is in trouble even though he knows he’s done nothing wrong.
Even when he’s spending time with his friends, some part of Shy’s mind constantly returns to his trauma, and he fears that he will never fully recover. He has become increasingly susceptible to moments of existential dread and often dwells on the insignificance of his life compared to the vastness of the ocean. During Rodney’s birthday party, Shy admits to himself that David’s death “messed something up in his head” (17), and when he cannot sleep that night, he finds himself looking out over the water where David killed himself. The vast ocean makes Shy feel like a “tiny, insignificant human,” and he understands for a moment “how someone could be moved to jump” (31).
These chapters also reveal that Shy thinks very highly of his friends, showing the same loyalty to them that he does to his family. Carmen is extremely important to him—not just for her looks, but for the fact that she seems to understand him and his experiences in a way no one else can. His inability to separate his desire to be Carmen’s friend with his desire to be her lover creates constant tension within Shy and between the two of them; he’s scared of going too far and ruining the friendship that is so important to him, but he can’t entirely suppress his feelings for her. After they kiss and Carmen pushes him away, Shy’s fear that he has “messed things up with the only girl that understood” shows how vital a part of his life she has become (45). Shy also cares deeply for Rodney, Kevin, and Marcus; he remembers how important Rodney’s dream to be a chef is to him, and he feels extremely grateful to Kevin for having his back with regards to the man in the black suit. His anxiety and guilt often cause Shy to feel isolated and insignificant, especially while he’s out on the open ocean, and having the others around him as a support system helps to stave off those feelings to an extent.
By Matt de la Peña