logo

28 pages 56 minutes read

Sherman Alexie

This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona

Fiction | Short Story | Adult | Published in 1993

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Spokane Falls

The reservation that Victor and Thomas live on is near Spokane Falls, which the story implies is a culturally important site to the tribe. Thomas, for example, mentions migrating salmon leaping up the waterfall, evoking the historical reliance of the Spokane people on salmon fishing. This natural wonder is now surrounded by the town of Spokane, Washington, and overtaken by American culture, evoking Alienation from Cultural Identity via imperialism. Nevertheless, the falls continue to play a culturally important role, appearing in Thomas’s dream as the prospective site of a vision and later serving as the place where Thomas and Victor plan to scatter the ashes of the latter’s father. The act of returning Victor’s father to the falls represents their desire to bring him home literally as well as figuratively, reintegrating him within the cultural life of the tribe. As Thomas puts it, “[Y]our father will rise like a salmon, leap over the bridge, over me, and find his way home” (327). Victor returning his father to Spokane Falls therefore also symbolizes the potential of accepting his cultural identity. This symbolism dovetails with the symbolism of water generally; it often suggests cleansing or letting go, while flowing water (as in a waterfall) evokes the natural course of life.

Jackrabbit

While driving through the desert on their way back to the reservation, Victor and Thomas remark on the “lack of animal life, the absence of water, of movement” (326). This setting evokes Victor’s Loneliness and Self-Isolation, as well as the broken links between many Indigenous Americans and their ancestral homelands. The jackrabbit that appears in the desert therefore initially comes as a sign of hope, hinting at the possibility of renewed cultural life. However, Thomas accidentally strikes the rabbit in his distraction, and the men pull over to find the animal dead. They joke that the rabbit must have died by suicide, further sealing its connections to the story’s depiction of reservation life, where despair is prevalent. However, they also accept the death and travel on. In a work that deals heavily with movement and the natural course of life, this suggests Victor’s acceptance of his father’s death.

Phoenix

Victor’s story is set into motion by the need to travel to Phoenix, Arizona, to settle his departed father’s affairs. Phoenixes—mythical birds that die and then rise again out of their own ashes—are symbols of rebirth and new beginnings. By traveling to Phoenix, Victor is metaphorically heading toward rebirth and reclamation of his Spokane identity. Significantly, Victor also goes to Phoenix to retrieve his father’s ashes, creating a parallel between the phoenix’s life cycle and the cyclical nature of human generations. By traveling to Phoenix, Victor becomes a part of the immortal life cycle of his culture, which passes from parents to children and is renewed with each new generation.

Storytelling

Storytelling is a vital component of many Indigenous American cultures, as it was the way in which tribal histories were passed down from generation to generation, entertaining and educating at the same time. During the colonization of the Americas, storytelling took on additional significance as a way for displaced tribes to stay connected to their homes and histories. In Alexie’s story, Thomas is compelled to keep this tradition alive despite the rejection of his peers on the reservation. Thomas believes that the stories come to him through his spiritual connection to his culture, bringing life to not only his personal memories and ideas but those of the tribe. In the conclusion, Thomas “[goes] into his house, close[s] the door behind him, and hear[s] a new story come to him in the silence afterward” (328). Alexie concludes with this act, which symbolizes the perseverance and preservation of Victor and Thomas’s cultural identity.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text