58 pages • 1 hour read
Erik LarsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Erik Larson identifies what he describes as fatal flaws in several key historical figures in Thunderstruck. The motif of fatal flaws appears throughout the text as a means of explaining actions, intentions, and motives. Larson identifies and isolates traits that explain repeated actions and motives.
Foremost in the narrative is the fatal flaw in Oliver Lodge’s character, which is described in terms of an inattentiveness to completing his research in any one area of exploration. It is a flaw that Lodge himself describes as having “been the cause of my not clinching many subjects, not following up the path on which I had set my feet” (25). Larson suggests that had Lodge continued his line of scientific inquiry into Hertzian waves in 1894, it could have been he and not Maroni who realized the vision of wireless communication. As it happened, Lodge “found himself distracted anew, at what would prove to be a critical moment in his career and in the history of science” (28).
Larson describes Marconi’s fatal flaw as “a social obtuseness that made him oblivious to how his actions affected others” (102). Throughout his life, this trait would result in lost allies, lost contracts, and the emergence of a host of foes who would rally skeptics against Marconi’s efforts. Larson suggests that this trait is responsible for much of the grief in Marconi’s life, both personal, romantic, and professional.
In Thunderstruck, the séance represents the 1900s culturally accepted fixation on exploring the unknown, especially the death realm, using methods many at the time thought of as scientific. Through the end of the Victorian era and into the early Edwardian era, the British population became fascinated by death, dying, and the great beyond. Larson notes that in the “mid-1890s Britain had 150 Spiritualist societies; by 1908 there would be nearly 400” (72). This, Larson explains, “was largely Darwin’s fault,” his revelation having “turned many others into the arms of Spiritualism and set them seeking concrete proof of an afterlife in the shifting planchettes of Ouija boards” (71). The era brought an end to religion as the only socially acceptable line of inquiry: “Reports of ghosts and poltergeists and premonitions-come-true became commonplace. Families acquired Ouija boards and scared themselves silly. Legendary mediums emerged” (58), revealing a Spiritualism easily encapsulated by the symbol of the séance.
A modern view of the occult is present in Thunderstruck in Larson’s description of Spiritualism. This is most apparent in Larson’s description of Lodge’s exploration of the afterlife. Larson writes, “Lodge—renowned physicist, professor at University College of Liverpool, member of the Royal Institution, revered lecturer, soon-to-be principal of Birmingham University, and destined for knighthood,” takes part in a séance, concluding that “things hitherto held impossible do actually occur” (61). Larson laments Lodge’s decision to focus on the occult rather than on wireless telegraphy, which, with the gift of hindsight, Larson knows to be a valuable pursuit. Of his “vulnerability to distraction,” Larson writes, “Up to this point this flaw in his character had caused him no great harm” (62). Concluding that Lodge’s career would be forever tarnished by his decision to explore the paranormal rather than wireless telegraphy, Larson reminds readers how differently the world of Spiritualism was viewed during the era through the repeated appearance of the séance, a symbol meant to remind readers not to view Lodge’s distraction, however historically vital, with modern reproach.
Larson characterizes ships at sea as lonely, isolated, and removed from civilization. At the time, ships were the primary means of traveling great distances: “This made for lonely times in the many places where wires did not reach, but nowhere was this absence felt more acutely than on the open sea” (38). The symbol of the solitary ship represents the era before Marconi’s device, a time called The Great Hush, when “this estrangement from the affairs of land” (38) was total. Ships at sea represent extreme isolation and the last frontier for communication. Wires connected land-based entities, but attempts at wire communication were incapable of conquering the oceans.
In the late 1890s, “the race among the great shipping companies to see whose liners could cross the Atlantic in the shortest time” (104) kicked off with the ultimate goal of decreasing the isolation of those onboard and returning passengers as quickly as possible to the fold of civilization. It was this vast wasteland that Marconi targeted for his wireless telegraphy, correctly understanding that the advantage his device offered was most easily demonstrated at the frontier of human communication capabilities.
After Marconi’s device is used to track the Montrose and its fugitive cargo, the loneliness of ships at sea is erased. Ships can now communicate with one another and with land. They are not solitary objects at the whims of nature, but rather tethered to humanity and to civilization such that even trivial things are transmitted from ship to shore.
By Erik Larson
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
European History
View Collection
Globalization
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Marriage
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Science & Nature
View Collection
The Power & Perils of Fame
View Collection
True Crime & Legal
View Collection